By Aaron Ziraks
NoLogoNeeded,com Staff Writer
Donté Stallworth came to Cleveland as a highly paid free agent. He played sparingly because of injuries for one year. He recorded 17 catches for 170 yards and one touchdown in 2008. About a year ago in Miami, Stallworth killed a pedistrian in a traffic accident that was 95 percent Stallworth's fault, who was driving under the influence of alcohol.
That pretty much sums up the Browns experience with Stallworth. On Sunday of the Super Bowl, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell reinstated Stallworth for the 2010 season. The Browns actions were swift announcing on Monday night they were cutting ties with Stallworth making him an unrestricted free agent.
I can see where Browns president Mike Holmgren is coming from. He just took over a team and doesn't want his first glimpse of the media spotlight as the Browns leader to be in a bad light. The fact also remains that Stallworth had a huge contract and keeping Stallworth may not have been fiscally responsible.
So why was it a bad idea to cut him?
1. Stallworth is a productive receiver when healthy
If you take a look at his stats he has only played 16 games three times in his seven-year career. Even with having his seasons cut short he still averaged 700 yards and five touchdowns, if you exclude his only season with the Browns. Taking a year off to let all of his hamstring issues subside did nothing but good things for him.
2. The contract isn't that big of deal
When he signed his seven-year, $35 million deal, people were expecting Stallworth to be a No. 1 receiver for the Browns. If you look at his stats, he has never been a No. 1 and doesn't have No. 1 receiver talent. But, in the right role he can be productive and stretch the field when asked to do so. Don't be angry at Stallworth for signing a deal that was much higher than what he should have received. Be mad at former GM Phil Savage.
Even though the contract looks huge, only $10 million of that is guaranteed. Anyway you look at it, Stallworth knows he screwed the pooch. Sitting him down and restructuring his contract would have been the right thing to do. He was grossly overpaid before he killed a guy. My guess would be that he would be more than happy to sit down and restructure his contract simply for the chance to get on the field and prove he belongs.
3. Athletes surprise you when they are backed into a corner
The one thing we all know about professional athletes is that they are ultra competitive and have egos that last for days (most of them at least). Being so full of pride is the reason they have gotten to the top of their profession and make ungodly amounts of money to play a game. If you think Donté Stallworth doesn't have an "I'm going to show everyone" mentality, you are sorely mistaken.
4. The Browns receiving corps is BAD
Don't get me wrong, Stallworth is not the end game. But I do believe given the right circumstance he can serve a purpose. Bringing in a high-level wide receiver free agent should be at the top of the Browns' list. Yet, getting Stallworth to stay for one year, with an option or two on the cheap, and stretch the field isn't a terrible idea. What if he has another season like he has averaged over his career (700 and 5)? I would take that in a heartbeat. This team needs help and I would rather not have Massaquoi as the Browns only option again next year. However, Massaquoi, Stallworth, and Insert High Level Free Agent Here (Vincent Jackson?) would be a formidable group.
5. Mangini never got a shot
You can love him or hate him, but the fact is Mangini gets guys to buy in and play hard for him. So I ask, if Mangini puts him to the test and Stallworth passes, the Browns end up with a guy that can produce. If he doesn't get it you trade him for a seventh rounder in 2030 and wash your hands of the situation. Stallworth has talent and can be effective in this league. He just needs to be used correctly.
©2008-2010 No Logo Needed All Rights Reserved
Contact us with comments, concerns or advertising opportunities:
Email: NoLogoNeeded@gmail.com
Twitter: @DonNoLogoNeeded; @Z_NoLogoNeeded
Comments
I disagree. You admit and I agree with you that Stallworth is a #2 receiver at best. Right now the Browns have several #2 and #3 guys. (Massaquoi looks like a good #2 option and Robiskie and Stuckey seem like #3-#4 possession slot guys as little as we seen of them)
What the Browns needed is to get rid of this guy who really wouldn't have much of a role on the team and clear the cap room and roster space for a #1 receiver and then maybe a couple of depth guys.
@ Jaws
The only difference is that none of those guys can stretch the field. Using Stallworth as a No. 3 guy would fit perfect especially to loosen the defense
Please...cut this druggie. He was drinking and doing drugs with Braylon before he murdered a man. Why keep trash like this around. He was never good. He is a perpetual drug addict and lazy unproductive player. Great move by Browns
All good reasons to keep Stallworth....that's why I think there were other things going on behind the scenes between the Browns and Stallworth. Like maybe they found some other things out that they didn't like. Maybe the pot thing....maybe just the fact it happened a day after he got his bonus.
I disagree about the accident. I say that the fault (all of it) was on the part of the jayrunner Reyes (he was trying to catch a bus)
Stallworth was railroaded by Florida authorities. He should not have plead guilty,
rmk/akron
The Browns are better off without Donte Stallworth
I am extremely disappointed in the NFL to allow him to play....
He was DRUNK when he got behind the wheel of his Bentley....He MURDERED a man with his car -
He should be banned from playing the NFL foreever!
The NFL needs to get rid of the THUGS and criminals
In the real world, you or I would not likely be able to get our jobs back if we MURDERED a man....why is it different for jocks?
too bad there are desperate teams that will sign a man guilty of MURDER
The criminal stuff get decided outside the NFL, so let that go. I don't necessarily agree with his sentence but he did his time and it cost him a ton of money.
I think half the NFL players are accidents waiting to happen. It is not the Boy Scouts. If they get rid of all the thugs and criminals, we'll have a touch football league wearing dresses. The mentality it takes to be a professional football player, dictates an aggressive, over-confident, risk takers. The same with our police departments and military; do you want Joe Blow CPA at those jobs too. I apologize to accountants.
Stallworth is a talent that we should not have let go. Is he a number 1 receiver in the NFL: No; but on the Browns, Yes. It is not like we are deep in WRs. I don't agree with what he did but for heavens sake, I saw a guy with 13 DUIs get arrested the other day. We have a drinking/drug problem is the U.S.